
The generator proposal that promises too much
A homeowner says they want the whole house to work in an outage. Ten minutes later you learn what they actually have in mind. The well pump has to run. They want the freezer to stay cold. They can live without the dryer, but they would like to know what keeping the central air would add. By evening the competing proposals on their table say “whole home” and list two different prices. Both sales visits may have been thorough. The documents have lost the most important part of the conversation.
If you buy electrical estimating software for residential service, bring that fictional job to the demo. Ask the vendor to produce the page the family gets. A takeoff can tell a shop what materials it expects to buy. A homeowner still needs to know what happens when the lights go out.
Make the first option answer the outage question
Hand the estimator a short list with three columns headed “Must run,” “Would like” and “Can wait.” Put the well pump and freezer in the first, air conditioning in the second and the dryer in the third. Ask for a base proposal that identifies the loads it is intended to support, alongside the assumptions the electrician still needs to verify. Watch whether that list survives on the customer’s copy or disappears into an internal note.
A household list is a brief for a qualified designer. It cannot select a unit on its own. Generac’s sizing guide explains the difference between running demand and the extra power some equipment needs at startup, and describes the role of an on-site assessment. A proposal can make that dependency intelligible in one sentence. “We’ll confirm whether this option can start the well pump and air conditioner together before we finalize the equipment.”
Change one request while the estimator watches
Now move cooling into the must-run column. Ask the vendor to revise the option and show where the earlier scope is retained. If the total changes, have a second reader identify why. A change in equipment, controls or site work should have a description a family can understand. If approval depends on confirming the gas supply or equipment location, ask for the responsible person and next step on the same page.
Offer maintenance separately in this exercise. The buyer should be able to decline a recurring service and still identify the installed scope and price. When the two test readers disagree about what is optional, keep the disputed page. It will tell a purchasing team more than another screen recording of the estimate editor.
Hand the result to the office
Have dispatch open the approved version and tell the crew which equipment and load assumptions the household accepted. Score three tasks separately: identifying protected loads, tracing the changed price and retrieving the accepted version. Record how much help each reader needed. A tool can excel at producing a bid and still leave the office rebuilding the sale from the advisor’s memory.
Mantel’s proposal software demo questions were written for HVAC buyers. The question worth borrowing for electrical work is what a homeowner actually sees. For a shorter cross-vendor exercise, use our five-minute proposal software test. Give every vendor the same household, including the same last-minute change.




