A worker reading a tablet beside a workshop window
A worker reading a tablet beside a workshop window
November 20, 2026
4 min read

The five-minute proposal software test

The vendor’s sample furnace proposal looks excellent on the conference-room screen. The equipment images are crisp. The advisor advances through the options without a wrong turn. Then someone from dispatch asks a question the demo has not covered. “What happens if the customer calls back and changes just one thing?”

Give that question five minutes in every demo. Use a dummy customer, a test email address and the same fictional job for every vendor. Start with two options already sent to the household. The homeowner wants to retain an existing thermostat and share a revised estimate with a partner. Put a phone on the table. The buyer should leave with the document the homeowner received as well as the vendor’s answers. Use the editable HVAC proposal worksheet to prepare identical scope and pricing for each vendor.

Start the clock after the original is sent

For the first two minutes, hand the controls to someone who would use the product in the field. Ask them to revise only the relevant option, explain the change and send the update. Watch whether the other option quietly changes too. Record where the old price and the new price live. The difference matters when an installer opens a job whose scope changed between the first visit and approval.

Let the user try before a product specialist steps in. The UK Government Service Manual describes this approach in its guide to moderated usability testing. Give someone a realistic task in neutral language and observe where they need help. “Keep the old thermostat” is a fair task. “Click the pencil beside accessories” supplies the answer.

Put the phone in the buyer’s hand

Spend the next two minutes in the customer’s inbox. Open the revision without an employee login. Find the installed price, verify which control stays and send the proposal to a second test device. Can the second reader tell that this is a revision? Return to the first email and see what its original link displays. Either a retained historical version or a link to a clearly identified current version can be workable. The shop needs to know which behavior it is buying.

In the final minute, give dispatch a turn. Ask the office user to show which version the customer can approve and which version the crew would receive. Stop at five minutes even if the task runs long. Write down where the team stopped. A product can still be suitable if a task needs training. Buyers deserve to see where that training will fall.

Keep the output with the score

Score each task as completed alone, completed with help or unfinished. Beside each mark, record a fact, such as “old link displayed the new total without a revision date.” Keep the screenshots from the dummy job together so the team can revisit differences the next morning.

For the rest of the demo, Mantel’s HVAC proposal software checklist offers questions about the field and homeowner experience. Put those questions to Mantel and the other shortlisted vendors under the same conditions. The result of this exercise is a record of what your own staff could do with one ordinary change. That is worth taking into a purchase meeting.

For a trade-specific demo brief, try the residential generator proposal test.

Frequently asked questions

How do we score a task the vendor finishes for us?

Mark it “completed with help” and write down the intervention. An advisor who needs a one-time permission change faces a different rollout cost from one who needs office staff to rebuild every revision. Give the second vendor the same starting permissions and the same task.

What if the demo cannot send an estimate to an outside inbox?

Record the delivery and sharing steps as unverified. Ask for a sample sent through the customer-facing workflow before making a purchase decision. A screenshot can show the layout, but it cannot tell you whether a forwarded link opens on a second phone.

Other Articles

Other Articles

An HVAC proposal your customer can compare

An editable worksheet for the equipment, labor, exclusions and next steps a household needs in writing.

Can the homeowner explain the quote back?

Four questions an advisor can use to hear what actually came across at the kitchen table.

Three ways to write a water heater estimate

A plumber’s guide to showing a like-for-like replacement, a higher-capacity option and a different system without burying the trade-offs.

Two branches, one close rate. Are they counting the same thing?

A worked example for comparing replacement sales without losing the denominator.