Two workshop colleagues discussing work at a bench
Two workshop colleagues discussing work at a bench
November 20, 2026
4 min read

Two branches, one close rate. Are they counting the same thing?

Two branch managers bring a 50% close rate to the same operations meeting. One wants another advisor. The other wants help filling the calendar. Before the owner moves a single lead, someone should ask each manager to read the fraction aloud. “Fifty percent of what?” can change the entire staffing conversation.

Consider a fictional month. East books 100 replacement appointments. Ten cancel before a visit. Its advisors deliver 90 estimates and sell 45 jobs. West books 100 appointments, delivers 80 estimates and sells 50 jobs. East’s manager divides 45 by 90. West’s manager divides 50 by 100. Both report 50%. They have described different stretches of the business.

Follow a hundred bookings through each branch

On a booking basis, East closes 45% and West closes 50%. Among customers who actually receive an estimate, East closes 50% and West closes 62.5%. West also has 20 bookings that never became estimates, twice East’s count. That is enough to ask why those appointments fell out. It is too little evidence to conclude that dispatch missed calls or that West’s advisors give better presentations.

Pull a few job records. A customer who canceled before the van left, a service call that proved repairable and a replacement visit awaiting a technical review can all appear as a blank estimate field. They call for different responses. Keep the counts visible even when the owner wants a single rate for the weekly dashboard.

Agree on when the clock starts and stops

Use one row per replacement opportunity. A revised estimate for the same furnace should update that row. If several options for one house show up as several chances to sell, the most thorough advisor can appear to have the weakest results. Give each job a booking date, a visit outcome, the first proposal date and a signed date where applicable.

Then compare estimates issued in the same period after the same amount of time has passed. A September proposal approved in October belongs in the September group when the question is how September’s estimates performed after 30 days. It belongs in October when finance asks what sold that month. Keep those views separately labeled.

Choose a measure the manager can act on

Mantel’s weekly sales metrics guide uses jobs run as the denominator for its close rate and reads that figure beside average ticket and booked sales per job run. If your shop adopts that definition, spell out what counts as a job run. A completed visit pending an estimate can belong in the visit count even though there is nothing for the homeowner to sign.

The same care applies to an outside benchmark. ACCA’s Contractor of the Future study surveyed more than 1,000 HVACR contractors and reports differences in close rates by the number of options presented. Before setting a branch target from a survey, ask whether the comparison group handles the same work and counts a sale at the same point.

At the next meeting, put the counts alongside the percentages and split referrals from other leads if the branches receive different mixes. Ask East to review a handful of delivered estimates still awaiting a decision. Ask West to explain its missing visits. Next week each manager can bring back something more informative than a league table of advisors.

Frequently asked questions

Do three options on one proposal count as three sales opportunities?

For the branch comparison in this example, count one household decision as one opportunity. Keep option count as a separate field. Otherwise an advisor who offers three alternatives can post a lower close rate than a colleague who wins exactly as many households with one option apiece.

What happens when a September estimate sells in October?

For a September estimate cohort, keep the eventual sale with September and apply the same observation window to every branch. For an October booked-sales report, count it in October. Label the date field on both reports so nobody adds those two counts together.

Other Articles

Other Articles

An HVAC proposal your customer can compare

An editable worksheet for the equipment, labor, exclusions and next steps a household needs in writing.

Can the homeowner explain the quote back?

Four questions an advisor can use to hear what actually came across at the kitchen table.

Three ways to write a water heater estimate

A plumber’s guide to showing a like-for-like replacement, a higher-capacity option and a different system without burying the trade-offs.

The five-minute proposal software test

Give every vendor the same replacement job. Then watch what reaches the homeowner’s phone.